Who in the hell is Daniel Cross?
I live My Life In Stories.
There were people who would swear they knew Daniel Cross.
Not casually.
Not in the way people say they know the man who lives three houses down or the father they see every Saturday morning at the ball field.
They knew him.
They would lean forward when they said it.
“I know exactly who Daniel is.”
And then they would tell you.
One man would tell you Daniel was dangerous.
Not dangerous in any obvious way. Daniel was smarter than that, he would say. He could lie without changing his breathing. He could make a person question a conversation they had stood in the room and heard with their own ears.
A snake in tall grass.
That was how one person described him.
Somebody else would nearly laugh.
Daniel?
Not Daniel Cross.
They knew the man who stopped when somebody was stranded on the side of the road.
The man who showed up when somebody was sick.
The man who spent half a Saturday helping someone fix something and refused money when they tried to pay him.
If there was trouble somewhere, Daniel had an odd habit of appearing near the front of it.
No announcement.
No applause.
He just showed up.
Good man, they would say.
One of the best.
Another person knew about the lies.
Someone knew about the women.
Someone knew about money.
Someone knew a story in which Daniel had been the only person in the room willing to do the decent thing.
Someone else would tell you Daniel Cross had never done a decent thing in his life unless there was something in it for Daniel Cross.
And every one of them would say it with the confidence of a witness who had seen the thing happen.
I know who he is.
The women were no more helpful.
Especially the women from before Claire.
There were some who could barely stand to hear his name.
Years had passed and they still spoke about him carefully, as though saying too much might somehow invite him back into the room.
They would tell you he had gotten inside their heads in a way no one else ever had.
That loving him had made them question what was real.
That leaving him had not immediately ended it.
Stay away from him, they would say.
Whatever you think you see, stay away.
And then there were the others.
Women Daniel had loved, dated, left, returned to, disappeared from and somehow never entirely lost.
Years later, they were still there.
Not necessarily waiting in any way they would admit to.
Just present.
A message answered.
A door that never quite locked.
A familiar place Daniel seemed able to wander back into whenever one chapter of his life ended and another had not yet begun.
He could vanish for years and somehow still be welcomed as though he had only stepped outside.
That complicated things.
Because how terrible could a man be if women who knew him intimately kept letting him come back?
Then again, how good could he be if other women carried the memory of him like an old injury?
Maybe one group had misunderstood him.
Maybe the other had.
Maybe both were telling the truth.
That was the strange thing about Daniel Cross.
The evidence never agreed.
Even his kindness created questions.
Was he generous because he was generous?
Was he helpful because being needed made him feel important?
Did he rescue people because he loved people?
Or because emergencies were simple?
A broken truck required tools.
A sick friend required showing up.
A crisis had a problem to solve.
People were harder.
People eventually asked questions.
People eventually wanted explanations.
People eventually wanted to know what Daniel thought when there was nothing to fix.
Maybe that was unfair.
Maybe he was simply kind.
Nobody knew.
There were people who believed Daniel lied because lying benefited him.
Others thought he lied because confrontation frightened him.
Some believed he enjoyed keeping people uncertain.
Others believed uncertainty followed him because Daniel himself never seemed certain what he wanted until he had already damaged the thing he had.
Maybe he had learned it somewhere.
Childhood was an obvious suspect.
Childhood always is.
Perhaps there had been a little boy once who learned that honesty created consequences.
Maybe affection had disappeared on him before.
Maybe he learned that the safest way to move through the world was to study the room first and become whatever version of himself would survive it.
Funny enough for this person.
Strong enough for that one.
Useful here.
Soft there.
Charming when charm worked.
Silent when silence worked better.
Maybe somewhere along the way that little boy learned something far more dangerous.
Maybe he learned that being loved was easier if nobody ever saw enough of him to decide they did not like what was underneath.
And if that was true, then Daniel Cross had spent a lifetime protecting himself from a rejection that may never have come.
Because years later, there would be a woman who saw more than he seemed to understand.
Not everything.
Apparently nobody got everything.
But enough.
Enough to see the flaws.
Enough to see the lies.
Enough to see the selfishness and the fear and the strange disappearing acts and the parts of him that did not fit cleanly beside the good ones.
And she loved him anyway.
Not blindly.
That would have been easier to dismiss.
Claire was not stupid.
She was sharp as a whip.
Successful.
Beautiful in the sort of way people noticed without her needing them to.
She had a life that did not require Daniel Cross to make it interesting.
And still, knowing more than most people ever would, she chose him.
She came back to a town that was close enough to her history to recognize her but far enough away that it had never quite been home.
And she chose Daniel Cross there.
She married him.
She built a life beside him.
And whatever else could be said about Claire, there was one thing that seemed almost embarrassingly simple.
Her heart was true where Daniel was concerned.
She loved that man with everything she had.
Which made the possibility almost unbearable.
What if Daniel had spent his entire life hiding because somewhere deep inside him he believed that if anyone ever saw the whole man, they would leave?
What if the great irony of his life was that somebody finally stayed long enough to see the contradictions and loved him anyway?
And what if there was something inside Daniel Cross that would never allow him to believe it?
There is a particular kind of sadness in being offered the thing you have spent your whole life protecting yourself from wanting.
Worse still if you let it disappear before you ever understand that you had it.
But maybe none of that was true.
Maybe there was no frightened little boy underneath Daniel Cross.
Maybe there was no wound waiting to explain the adult man.
Maybe people invented childhood stories because human beings dislike unanswered questions.
An unexplained man feels unfinished.
Give him a wound and suddenly the chapters line up.
But nobody knew what Daniel had learned as a boy.
Nobody knew whether there was anything to learn.
Maybe Daniel knew exactly who he was.
Maybe somewhere inside him there was a perfectly coherent set of thoughts, fears, wants and loyalties that he simply refused to show anybody.
Maybe there was a reason for that.
Maybe there wasn’t.
Perhaps he guarded himself because something once happened when he did not.
Perhaps he guarded himself because secrecy gave him control.
Perhaps there was no guarding at all.
Perhaps everyone else kept searching for a locked door in a house that had never had a room behind it.
Every explanation worked for at least one version of Daniel.
None worked for all of them.
The charitable explanations collapsed against the cruelty.
The cruel explanations collapsed against the kindness.
The theory that he did not care about anyone failed whenever someone remembered the things he had done for them.
The theory that he loved deeply became harder to understand beside the people he had apparently been able to leave without turning around.
The theory that he was calculated required ignoring all the times he seemed impulsive.
The theory that he was impulsive required ignoring all the moments that looked suspiciously calculated.
Daniel Cross could be used to prove almost anything about Daniel Cross.
The witnesses kept arriving.
A friend.
An enemy.
A former wife.
A former girlfriend.
A woman who still answered his calls.
A woman who never wanted to hear his name again.
Someone he helped.
Someone he hurt.
Someone who trusted him with everything.
Someone who would not trust him with the time of day.
Put them all in separate rooms and ask them to describe Daniel Cross.
You might think you had interviewed six different men.
And sooner or later somebody would ask the obvious question.
What about Claire?
That was where people tended to lower their voices.
Claire was the most recent wife.
The one everybody had seen him build a life with.
The one who had been there long enough to make people assume that whatever mysteries remained about Daniel Cross, surely she knew where the bodies were buried.
Metaphorically speaking.
Probably.
She had known his routines.
His moods.
His family.
His habits.
His private stories.
She had seen the helpful Daniel everybody praised.
She had seen the cold Daniel other people warned about.
She had seen the charming one.
The angry one.
The soft one.
The distant one.
The husband.
The father.
The man who showed up.
The man who vanished while still standing in the room.
She had seen enough versions of Daniel Cross that surely, if anybody could sort them into the real man and the disguises, it would be Claire.
So one evening, before she left town, somebody finally asked her.
Who the hell is Daniel Cross?
Claire stood beside her car for a second.
There was nothing dramatic about her answer at first.
She just looked puzzled.
Almost amused by the expectation.
Five months had passed since she had seen him.
Not only him.
Anything.
She had not heard his voice.
She had not seen a photograph.
She had not heard a recording.
She had not accidentally caught his face in the background of somebody else’s picture.
There had been no glimpse across a parking lot.
No familiar voice from another room.
No evidence at all that Daniel Cross still occupied physical space somewhere in the world.
For months, he had existed only in memory.
And memory had started doing what memory does.
His face had softened around the edges.
His voice had become harder to summon.
Sometimes she could remember exactly how he looked walking into a room.
Other times she had to reach for it.
Which was strange.
Once, Claire had known his face better than her own reflection.
Now she opened the driver’s door.
Got inside.
Closed it.
The window rolled down.
She pulled out a cigarette and held it between her lips while she searched for the lighter.
Everybody waited.
Surely this was the answer.
The final witness.
The woman smart enough to recognize a lie.
Close enough to have seen behind the curtain.
The woman who had chosen Daniel Cross when she had every ability not to.
Claire flicked the lighter.
The flame caught.
She took the first drag, leaned toward the open window and looked back at them.
“I have no fucking clue.”
Then she put the car in reverse.
And just like that, Claire was gone too.
Which left everybody else with exactly what they had before.
Stories.
Maybe the women who warned people about Daniel knew him.
Maybe the women who kept answering his calls knew him.
Maybe the people who called him heroic were right.
Maybe the people who called him dangerous were right too.
Maybe Daniel Cross was extraordinarily kind.
Maybe he was extraordinarily cruel.
Maybe he could rescue strangers and devastate people he loved.
Maybe he could mean something completely when he said it and still walk away from it later.
Maybe every version was real.
Or maybe Daniel Cross had spent his entire life allowing every person to know only the version of him that existed between them.
And if that was true, there was only one person left who could ever settle the question.
Daniel.
Maybe he knows.
Maybe he has always known.
Maybe beneath every version there is a private truth he has protected so fiercely that nobody else has ever been permitted to see it.
Maybe there is a reason.
Maybe there isn’t.
Maybe somewhere there is still that little boy who decided it was safer to be loved in pieces than risk being seen whole.
Or maybe even that is just another story somebody invented about Daniel Cross.
There is no answer waiting at the end of this story.
No childhood revelation that suddenly makes every version line up.
No villain unmasked.
No misunderstood hero vindicated.
Just a man who has moved through the world leaving wildly different versions of himself behind.
A town full of witnesses.
A history full of women.
People who love him.
People who hate him.
People who would trust him with their lives.
People who would tell you to run.
Maybe someday Daniel Cross will decide to tell the truth about who he is.
Maybe he already has, in pieces, to different people at different times.
Maybe nobody, including Daniel, has ever held all the pieces at once.
And somewhere down the highway, the woman everybody thought would finally explain Daniel Cross is driving away with the window cracked, cigarette smoke curling out behind her, knowing only two things for certain.
She had seen all of the different versions of Daniel Cross that local folklore told, and she loved him.
Judith L. Hampton
Attorney-at-Law
Hampton Law Firm
Comments